Abstract
How should law respond to transformative technologies whose benefits are inseparable from their risks? This Article argues that the answer lies not in binary choices between permission and prohibition, but in what might be called zones of contingent permission: legal frameworks that allow deployment of new technologies while requiring measures to detect and prevent specific harms. The concept emerges from an unlikely source: the ongoing litigation over whether and when training generative AI models on copyrighted works constitutes infringement.
Recent victories for Anthropic and Meta in copyright class actions might suggest to some that AI training has been vindicated as fair use, but deeper analysis shows that will only sometimes be true. This Article explains why the boundary between permissible and infringing AI conduct will be jagged rather than smooth: The copyright liability of AI developers depends on critical facts such as the degree of training data memorization and the extent to which that memorization manifests in outputs, which in turn must be measured against the infringement threshold of substantial similarity. Not only do these technical and legal considerations interact, but they may also be highly sensitive to the type of work at issue, such that the same computational process applied to a music model and a text model might produce dramatically different copyright risk.
That jagged frontier is only the beginning of the story. Drawing on Ronald Coase's insight that legal rules are starting points for adaptation and negotiation rather than final allocations, this Article argues that the extensive literature on AI and copyright has focused almost exclusively on fair use while ignoring what comes next. AI companies that build systems to monitor and filter infringing outputs will not only reduce their legal exposure—they will create a deal point. The history of YouTube's Content ID suggests that copyright safety infrastructure can become the foundation of a billion-dollar licensing industry benefiting developers, rightsholders, and users alike.
Citation
Matthew Sag,
Copyright's Jagged Frontier,
76 Duke Law Journal
367-452
(2026)
Available at: https://scholarship.law.duke.edu/dlj/vol76/iss3/1